In The Washington Post, the editorial board says "Tsk-tsk": ‘Really quite disastrous’. Excerpt:
As the world's worst outbreak of cholera continues to ravage Haiti, international donors have averted their gaze.
Humanitarian relief groups, short of cash, are folding their tents. A pilot project to vaccinate Haitians against the disease, recently undertaken at a cost of $400,000, reached only 1 percent of the population, with no immediate prospect of expansion. Of the 100 or so cholera treatment centers that sprang up around the country after the disease was detected 19 months ago, fewer than a third remain.
The United Nations’ humanitarian coordinator for Haiti, Nigel Fisher, said this month that donors have so far met just 9 percent of the $230 million U.N. appeal for 2012 — not only for cholera but for a range of relief programs including flooding, tent cities and food insecurity. “It’s really quite disastrous,” he said.
Meanwhile, cholera’s deadly toll has mounted in the Western Hemisphere’s poorest country. Unknown in Haiti for a century before the first cases appeared in October 2010, cholera has now killed 7,100 people, infected more than 550,000 and hospitalized nearly 300,000.
It has also spread across the border to the Dominican Republic, killing more than 400 people there. Five percent of Haiti’s 10 million people have already been infected, and health experts estimate that 200,000 could contract the disease this year.
I know I'm becoming a crank on the subject of the PAHO prediction of 200,000 cases this year. And I'm getting worse. At this rate, I'll soon start assuming that any argument invoking "experts" is bogus.
But the 200,000 argument has told me more than I want to know about some important institutions.
It's told me that PAHO is making stuff up about Haiti (or if it's not, it's failing to tell us where it got the number). That speaks very poorly for the integrity of PAHO and WHO, of which it's a part.
It also tells me that major news media, including The Washington Post, are credulously accepting what they're told, instead of testing the validity of those experts' estimates. If any reporters on the ground in Haiti are still covering cholera, they're not questioning PAHO either—though it would make quite a story.
Finally, it tells me that even in public-health agencies, politics trumps health. And in the media, Haiti is forever framed as a no-hope country, about which we can moralize without knowing what the hell we're talking about.
Recent Comments