Sandra, one of my favourite commenters, wrote about the preceding story:
Glad the the Italian news agency Ansa wrote the article anyway.
I'm anxious for journalists to start stepping up to the plate on every single issue that affects our globe.
And why wouldn't WHO be advising people on such a serious possible scenario?
With affection and respect, I'll have to disagree.
During the SARS outbreak, WHO issued a travel advisory against going to Toronto. It had a disastrous economic impact. The city finally imported The Rolling Stones, at huge expense, to hold a concert that would bring people back to the city.
Were any lives saved by the travel advisory? Probably not. Toronto simply learned, at great expense, what can happen when a scary new disease breaks out in a big city.
So I would not expect WHO to issue a warning about taking Tamiflu to Beijing. If a real H2H outbreak of H5N1 had been documented in Beijing, a travel advisory would be appropriate, but almost irrelevant. No one would go to China anyway.
So Ansa stepped up to the plate, all right, and then whacked the umpire across the head. It was sheer misinformation.
I wouldn't be surprised to find out it was conscious disinformation: A deliberate attempt to embarrass the Chinese and compromise the Olympics.
Having lived in China during the great campaign against "spiritual pollution" in 1983-84, I am no fan of the Beijing government. I have not forgiven them for Tiananmen Square. I consider the Olympics themselves a pretext for an orgy of pointless national hysteria by all participants.
But something smells about this story, just as something smells about the sudden eruption of Tibet liberationists as that stupid torch was schlepped about the planet.
Having lived to the age of 67 without the blessing of a failing memory, I can vividly recall bogus protests that led to the overthrow of governments the United States found inconvenient: Iran in 1953, Guatemala in 1954, Chile in 1973, even sorry little Grenada in 1983. Other governments, like those of Japan, Germany and Italy, were simply bought and paid for, like the allegiance of the Afghan warlords in 2001.
I'm sorry if I offend some of my American readers, but the role of the CIA in undermining other countries is all too well documented—by Americans.
In one of the greatest ironies in modern history, "communist" China is now bankrolling the imperial adventures of its old foe the US. The rulers of Beijing may not be serious reds any more, but they remember Lenin's famous dictum: "The capitalists will sell us the rope that we hang them with."
The well-educated folks in Langley, Virginia have read their Lenin too, but they also remember another old proverb: "When you owe the bank a thousand dollars and you can't pay it, you have a problem. When you owe the bank a million dollars and you can't pay it, the bank has a problem."
Giving China a discreet kick in the shins, on the eve of the Olympics, is an obvious way to remind Beijing that the US can make life hard for its adversaries (and creditors) without sending in the cruise missiles and Marines.
When I start surfing my sources every morning, I do so with an attitude of skepticism verging on paranoia. I have spent almost seven decades being lied to by champions, and I expect an outbreak of pandemic flu long before I expect an outbreak of government honesty—whether Chinese, Vietnamese, Indian, or American. Lying, after all, got those governments where they are today. Why should they abandon a winning policy?
We are going to have enough confusion, fright and misinformation in a pandemic even under the best of conditions. Skepticism about scare stories like the Ansa report is just basic mental hygiene.
Recent Comments